Fallen Animal Scheme dispute escalates as knackeries stop sheep and horse collections

The Animal Collectors' Association says affiliated knackeries have stopped collecting fallen sheep and horses and will not notify on-farm deaths, while DAFM says it remains open to talks.

A dispute between knackery operators and Ireland’s Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) over the Fallen Animal Scheme has entered a second week, with the Animal Collectors’ Association (ACA) saying affiliated knackeries will no longer collect fallen sheep and horses.

The ACA said the change applies from this week. It also said knackeries will not notify the department of on-farm animal deaths. The association confirmed the move as its dispute with DAFM continued.

The ACA said it submitted a 'comprehensive, sustainable business case' to DAFM before the Fallen Animal Scheme expired on September 30. The proposal, according to the association, set out mechanisms for a fair and workable scheme and included options intended to limit increases in the rates charged to farmers.

According to the ACA, fallen sheep collected by its affiliated knackery operators have not been prepared and presented to DAFM veterinarians for scrapie sampling since Monday, October 19. The association said the department had repeated a historical pattern of waiting for schemes to fully expire, forcing knackery operators into an escalating reduction of vital services.

The ACA said it remained committed to providing an environmental and biosecurity service to Irish agriculture. It called on DAFM to return immediately with a meaningful proposal that protects the infrastructure of the collection system without placing an additional burden on farmers.

DAFM said the Fallen Animal Scheme is an important element of Ireland’s livestock infrastructure. A department spokesperson said funding through the scheme supports farmer access to fallen animal collections and protects animal health. The spokesperson said the department is continuing to engage on the matter and remains open and available for constructive dialogue and negotiations.

The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers’ Association (ICMSA) said any solution to the dispute 'better not involve higher charges on farmers'. Eamon Carroll, ICMSA deputy president, said the solution must come from within the department’s own funds.

The disruption covers the two collection categories identified by the ACA, fallen sheep and fallen horses, as well as the notification of on-farm deaths. The dispute concerns the operation of the Fallen Animal Scheme and the rates associated with collections. The department’s statement did not say whether it would adopt the ACA proposal or set out a timeline for further talks. The disagreement remains unresolved as the dispute enters a second week.

DM

Dario Melnik

Dario is a harvest and post-harvest systems editor covering combines, forage equipment, balers, grain bins and dryers, grading, sorting, washing, and freezing lines for commercial agriculture. His analysis uses measurable parameters such as harvest loss percentage, grain moisture targets, bale density, line throughput, IQF product core temperature, and cold-chain temperatures under stated operating assumptions rather than guaranteed yields. He helps farm operations leads, plant managers, and procurement teams compare equipment fit, hygiene access, service requirements, and documentation before purchase.