Beauty scientists urge context and consistency in fight against misinformation

A CTPA conference panel examined how industry and government scientists can explain beauty science clearly, consistently and in context.

Beauty companies and scientists need to make complex evidence easier to understand, speak with greater consistency and engage consumers where misinformation is already circulating, according to speakers at the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Perfumery Association's first scientific conference.

The members-only event at Central Hall Westminster in London gathered government and industry representatives to examine how scientific evidence, regulatory decisions and public understanding can align at a time of information overload.

Putting risk in context

Caroline Rainsford, CTPA director of science, said science communication is central to every role. She described explaining that an ingredient banned in nail polish would require wearing two kilograms of the product on the nails to approach the level associated with harm, saying context helps consumers interpret risk.

Marc Pissavini, sun research lab director at Coty, endorsed context and cited an Olympic swimming pool analogy for communicating very small concentrations. He said a person drinking two litres a day would need roughly 4,500 years to consume one pool, helping audiences understand that a drop in such a volume is limited. He argued that combating misinformation starts with giving consumers ways to measure and understand claims.

Consistency and peer review

Pissavini also stressed consistency as a basis for credibility, calling on dermatologists, doctors and companies to communicate as a collective ‘we’ rather than as separate ‘I’s. He is editor of the peer-reviewed International Journal of Cosmetic Science and said maintaining peer review is essential, though the field faces challenges in finding reviewers and reaching readers inside and outside the industry.

Wendy Middleton, chief scientific officer and director for science at the UK Office for Product Safety and Standards, said the idea of a single voice is worth exploring but noted that scientists are not especially good at it. She said credible science depends on critique and peer review, while the profession should become more thoughtful about how it communicates internally and externally.

Rainsford added that the industry must demystify peer review, since many people—including some within the sector—do not understand the process. She said transparency about what peer review involves will be important going forward.

Listening before correcting

Journalist, editor and beauty-science consultant Claire Coleman said correction should begin where misinformation is found. She argued that communicators must understand their audience's starting point, and that the industry should focus on consumers who are uncertain and seeking clarity rather than on entrenched opponents.

Middleton agreed that starting from the audience's position is critical. She said government had often labelled certain consumers as difficult to reach, when the real problem was that their voices were difficult to hear; listening more actively was therefore essential.

Roger Pullin, head of chemicals policy and health at the UK Chemical Industries Association, advised avoiding technical terms and acronyms where possible. He said messages should be precise and clear while retaining the science, and that companies should present a balanced view, acknowledge uncertainty and address awkward questions directly. He acknowledged that this becomes difficult with complex subjects such as risk-based exposure.

Emma Meredith, CTPA director-general, closed the conference by saying that how the sector communicates science—and whether it does so well—is critical.

IL

Ingrid Lindqvist

Ingrid Lindqvist covers color cosmetics, nail gel systems, and nail art stickers as a specialist in shade consistency, cure behavior, and disposable wear performance. Her evidence reviews color measurement conditions, photoinitiator and wavelength boundaries for gel polish, sticker thickness in millimeters, and batch traceability without assuming any sample passes a given specification. She helps product development, quality, and sourcing teams compare pilot batches, supplier documentation, and removal or packaging trade-offs while excluding consumer tutorials, medical claims, and unsupported clean-beauty assertions.